Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting

Posted by hsimpsongrossman on March 1, 2015

This Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake was one heck of a roller coaster ride.

It was supposed to commemorate my return to the kitchen, following two consecutive trips abroad and a hectic examination period.

When I checked the Baked Sunday Mornings baking schedule, I was delighted to discover that the next baking project  was not only a sheet cake but a chocolaty one with peanut butter frosting to boot!  So many things I love in one cake!

Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting. Naked

Chocolate-peanut butter is my all time favorite combinations in ice creams (what I wouldn’t give for a scoop of Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Cookie Dough ice cream), cakes, bars and cookies.

And being a mother of five, who often bring their friends over, starving, straight after school, I love sheet cakes-those crowd pleasing, homey, snack-as-you-pass-by-the-kitchen cakes.

Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting.Dressed Up
Dressed Up

Building up so much hype around one cake could only mean one thing: something was bound to go wrong.  As indeed was the case.

First off, no matter what I did, I couldn’t insert a memory card into my camera.  Oh, and did I mention that my tech guy, aka Better Half was in New York?  That meant I had to make do with my three (or four?) years old iPhone 5 camera, which was pretty good two years ago but has lost its sharpness since.  I lost any interest in orchestrating photo scenes and what few pictures I did take reflected my discontented state of mind.

Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting. Out of the Box
Out of the Box

That’s not all.  We don’t have shortening in Israel.  Same goes for evaporated milk – none to be found over here.  And since I barely baked during my career days in New York, I missed my chance to familiarize myself with those ingredients and was in the dark regarding suitable substitutes.

A quick research on google led me to the conclusion I should substitute more butter for the shortening and malted milk powder for the evaporated milk.

Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting. Frosting
Makeshift Frosting

In keeping with my efforts to maintain sugar to a reasonable minimum, I decreased the amounts of sugars required, using ¾ of a cup granulated sugar and 1/2 a cup dark sugar for the sheet cake and 200 grams of powdered sugar for the frosting.

As there was no picture of this Chocolate Texas Sheet cake in the book, I let my imagination go wild and had a vision of a tall and airy cake with the fluffiest of frostings topping it.  Our sheet cake, however, came out pretty low and quite dense and the frosting was not at all fluffy, but rather heavy.

Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting Unlike any Other
Unlike any Other

Between the somewhat disappointing end product and the horrifying photos taken on my cell phone, I was not planning to post this one on my blog.  I was mentally prepared to sheepishly read about the marvelous concussions my colleagues would come up with and hope to redeem my reputation next time.

After a night in the fridge, I had no choice but to serve it on Saturday morning, warning everyone, that the cake is surely a complete flop and I would understand if they didn’t like it.

Surprisingly, though, my parents loved it, as did the boys! And while I was cutting myself yet another sliver, my mother came clean admitting to doing the same after having her first slice.  By Saturday night it was gone.

Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting. Close Up
Close Up

So, while the pictures aren’t great and I’m sure my friends at Baked Sunday Mornings will have much better versions of this Sheet cake to show for, I’m happily posting it on Spots on Pots after all.

For the recipe for this Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting, from Baked Occasions by Matt Lewis and Renato Poliafito, please go to Baked Sunday Mornings’ site.

Happy Baking!

Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting. Birds Eye View
Birds Eye View

Filed under Cakes

Tagged , , ,

10 thoughts on “Chocolate Texas Sheet Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting

  1. I left the shortening out of my cake too, and I don’t think it made much of a difference. I’m glad everybody liked it! Sometimes the things we think are disasters are the ones people like the best 🙂

  2. For all the substitutions and problems, I think the finished product looks great. So glad you were able to make it work and everyone loved it.

  3. I think your photos are just fine! And, your cake looks just as good as everyone else’s! You were smart to find good substitutes.

    • Thank you!
      I am about to look at the other cakes, now I’m a bit less scared..

  4. Your cook looks wonderful! I also wasn’t quite sure what to expect from the cake, but I googled sheet cake a few times beforehand to mentally prepare myself. The sheet cake I know in NJ is more of a two-layer birthday cake than the shallower Texas kind, but I think I might actually like this version better 🙂

    Also good to know the cake was delicious with less sugar! I will try those measurements next time!

  5. I’m glad it turned out tasty, I know how disheartening it can be when our hard work doesn’t seem to live up to our expectations. I think your cake looks pretty delicious.